hc8meifmdc|2010A6132836|ecommercewebsitedesign|tblnews|Text_News|0xfdff14a4000000007b05000001000600
افزایش میزان تنژگی بذر چهار جنس چمن با استفاده از تیمار
اسید
حسن صالحی و مرتضی خوشخوی
بخش علوم باغبانی،
دانشکده کشاورزی، دانشگاه شیراز، شیراز، ایران
چکیده:
چمن ها به طور معمول با بذر افزوده
می شوند. از مهم ترین مشکل های موجود در افزایش بذری برخی جنسهای چمن، می توان به
کمی درصد تنژگی و یا سرعت تنژگی اشاره نمود. پژوهش حاضر برای یافتن بهترین غلظت و
زمان تیمار اسید سولفوریک برای افزودن به میزان تنژگی بذر جنسهای چمن:Pers. Cynodon
dactylon [L.]، Festuca rubra L. var. rubra ‘Shadow’، Lolium perenne L. ‘Barball’ و Poa pratensis L.
‘Merion’ انجام شد. در آزمون اول، از
اسید سولفوریک به غلظت های 0 (شاهد)، 25، 50، 75 و 100 درصد به مدت زمان های 10،
15، 20، 25 و 30 دقیقه استفاده شد. در آزمون دوم، با به کار بردن بهترین تیمار
اسید برای هر جنس چمن اثر شرایط وجود یا نبودن نور در محیط بر میزان تنژگی مورد
بررسی قرار گرفت. هر تیمار با 4 تکرار، هر کدام با 100 عدد بذر قرار داده شده بر
روی کاغذ صافی درون پتری دیش های پلاستیکی، انجام شد. نتایج نشان داد که در Cynodon، تیمار اسید
50% به مدت 20 تا 25 دقیقه با درصد و سرعت تنژگی بیشتر در روشنایی؛ در Festuca، تیمار اسید
25% به مدت 15 دقیقه با درصد و سرعت تنژگی بیشتر در روشنایی؛ در Lolium، تیمار اسید
50% به مدت 10 دقیقه، با سرعت تنژگی بیشتر در تاریکی و در Poa، تیمار اسید
50% به مدت 15 تا 25 دقیقه با سرعت تنژگی بیشتر در تاریکی، مناسب ترین تیمارها می
باشند. بیشترین درصد تنژگی در چمن های Poa و Cynodon و کمترین آن در Festuca دیده شد. چمن
های Cynodon و Festuca به ترتیب بیشترین و کمترین سرعت تنژگی را دارا بودند. این روش کار
ساده با نتایج قابل ملاحظه می تواند جایگزین روش های وقت گیر و پرهزینه ای مانند
آماده سازی بذر شود.
Enhancing seed germination rate of four turfgrass
genera by acid treatments
H. Salehi
and M. Khosh-Khui
Department
of Horticultural Science| College of Agriculture| Shiraz University| Shiraz|
Iran
Abstract:
Turfgrasses
are commonly propagated by seeds. In some genera of turfgrasses| presence of
low germination percentages or rates are the main problems in seed propagation.
The present investigation was undertaken to determine the best concentration
and duration of sulfuric acid treatment for seeds of following turfgrass
genera: Cynodon dactylon [L.] Pers.; Festuca rubra L. var. rubra
‘Shadow’; Lolium perenne L. ‘Barball’ and Poa pratensis L.
‘Merion’. In the first experiment| sulfuric acid was used with concentrations
of 0 (control)| 25| 50| 75 and 100% for 10| 15| 20| 25 and 30 min. In the
second experiment| effects of light/dark (16/8) or dark conditions on
germination rates of different mentioned genera were investigated using the
best specific acid treatments. Each treatment was replicated 4 times with 100
seeds per replicate kept in plastic petri dishes. Results indicated that in Cynodon|
using 50% acid for 20-25 min had highest germination percentage (GP) and mean
daily germination (MDG) in light/dark; in Festuca| using 25% acid for 15
min had highest GP and MDG in light/dark; in Lolium using 50% acid for
10 min had highest MDG in dark and in Poa| using 50% acid for 15-25 min
had highest MDG in dark. Both Cynodon and Poa had the highest and
Festuca had the lowest GPs. Cynodon and Festuca had the
highest and lowest MDGs| respectively. This simple procedure| with considerable
results| may be replaced to time-consuming and expensive methods such as seed
priming.
Introduction:
The
turfgrass industry has undergone rapid growth in its attempts to meet the
public’s increasing demands for products and services (Turgeon| 2002). The rate
at which a new turf becomes established is influenced by specific procedures
used during propagation (Turgeon| 2002).
Direct
seeding is the least expensive and most efficient method for revegetating large
parcels of land with herbaceous species such as grasses (Trask and Pyke| 1998).
Different turfgrass species and cultivars vary substantially in the normal
percentage of viable seed contained in a seed lot (Simpson| 1990; Turgeon|
2002). Previously| germination characteristics of some perennial grasses have
been studied (Beckman et al.| 1993; Fujikura et al.| 1993; Young et
al.| 1977; Trask and Pyke| 1998; Tigabu and Oden| 2001). Mechanical
scarification and concentrated sulfuric acid treatment have been widely used to
improve seed germination of several hard-seeded species (Tigabu and Oden|
2001). Generally| turfgrass seeds have not hard seed coat| but their caryopses
are sandwiched between lemma and palea (Turgeon| 2002). There are few reports
on using mechanical scarification for seeds of grasses (e.g.| Trask and Pyke|
1998)| but in turfgrasses| sulfuric acid treatment had been used only for tall
fescue in tissue culture studies for callus production (Bai| 2001).
Optimum
acid concentration and exposure time vary with species (Argel and Paton| 1999).
The main aims of this study were to find an effective and practical treatment|
and to obtain the best cultural conditions to enhance seed germination rates in
each of four common turfgrass genera.
Materials
and Methods:
Turfgrass
genera
In
this investigation| four turfgrass genera| common bermudagrass Cynodon
dactylon [L.] Pers. (California origin); red fescue| Festuca rubra
L. var rubra ‘Shadow’; Perennial ryegrass| Lolium perenne L.
‘Barball’ and Kentucky bluegrass| Poa pratensis L. ‘Merion’ were used.
Experiment
1. Sulfuric acid treatments
Sulfuric
acid was used in concentrations of 25| 50| 75 and 100% for 10| 15| 20| 25 and
30 min along with control treatment.
Seeds
were soaked in cold sulfuric acid solutions (or distilled water in control
treatment) and then were thoroughly rinsed three times with tap water. The
rinsed seeds were kept under running tap water overnight.
Experiment
2. Light/dark or dark treatments
Based
on data obtained in experiment 1 for each genus| effects of light/dark (16/8 h)
or dark conditions on germination rates| mean daily germination (MDG)| were
studied and compared to controls.
Germination
tests
A
total of 400 seeds| 5 replications of 100 seeds| each was used in all
treatments. The seeds were placed on filter papers in 9 cm ?- sterilized plastic ptri
dishes| which kept moist with distilled water. Petri dishes were kept at 25±2
°C with 1000 lux illuminance (cool white fluorescent lamps) and 16/8 h
light/dark or dark conditions. They were monitored every day and moistened with
distilled water when needed. Seeds were considered germinated when the radicles
were about 3 mm long and discarded after counting. Germination tests were continued
up to 25 days. In each genus and treatment| the final germination date was the
time in which seed germination percentage (GP) was completed| or when the seeds
failed to germinate in 3 previous days.
Data
recording and statistical analysis
Number
of germinated seeds was daily recorded in all the experiments. Final GP and MDG
were calculated for each trial. Experiments were conducted as complete
randomized design with factorial arranging. The percentage data were arcsine
transformed before analysis (Zar| 1996). The presented percentage data in
Tables l and 3 are back-transformed. Data were analyzed by Factor analysis of
variance in experiment 1 and One-way analysis of variance in experiment 2 using
MSTATC program. Means were separated by Tuckey’s test at 1% level (P<0.01).
Results and Discussion:
Experiment
1.
Seed
GP was markedly increased using acid treatments especially in Cynodon| Festuca
and Lolium genera (Table l). Poa had the highest total mean
of seed GP followed by Cynodon| Lolium and Festuca. Turgeon
(2002) reported the variability among seed GP of different turfgrass species
and cultivars similar to these findings. According to ISTA (1999) some
turfgrass species such as Kentucky bluegrass (Poa pratensis L.) are slow
to germinate under optimal seed germination conditions and treatments. In
present study| using 50% acid for 15-25 min resulted in 100% seed GP in this
genus. It may be concluded that acid treatment can improve seed GPs of
turfgrass genera even in slow germinating ones.
In
general| using 50% acid for 10 to 25 min were the best treatments and resulted
to highest seed GP (Table 1). This result is in accordance to that reported by
Bai (2001) using 50% acid for 20 min with seeds of tall fescue in tissue
culture studies.
Table
1. Effects of different turfgrass genera| acid treatments and their
interactions on seed GP.
|
GP
|
Treatments
|
Turfgrass
genera
|
|
Cynodon
|
Festuca
|
Lolium
|
Poa
|
Mean
|
Control
|
45.5
mn1
|
42.5
n
|
58.5
l
|
91.5
efg
|
59.4
EF
|
Acid|
25%| 10 min
|
57.5
l
|
22.5
opq
|
59.5
kl
|
86.5
fghi
|
56.4
F
|
Acid|
25%| 15 min
|
59.0
kl
|
84.0
hi
|
58.5
l
|
85.0
ghi
|
71.6
C
|
Acid|
25%| 20 min
|
63.0
jkl
|
70.5
j
|
55.0
lm
|
84.5
ghi
|
68.3
CD
|
Acid|
25%| 25 min
|
70.0
jk
|
23.0
opq
|
60.0
jkl
|
91.5
efg
|
61.1
E
|
Acid|
25%| 30 min
|
83.0
i
|
22.0
opq
|
64.5
jkl
|
92.5
def
|
65.4
D
|
Acid|
50%| 10 min
|
94.0
cde
|
29.0
o
|
97.5
bc
|
97.0
bcd
|
79.4
A
|
Acid|
50%| 15 min
|
94.0
cde
|
23.0
opq
|
91.0
efgh
|
100
a
|
77.0
A
|
Acid|
50%| 20 min
|
98.0
bc
|
20.5
opq
|
91.5
efg
|
100
a
|
77.5
A
|
Acid|
50%| 25 min
|
98.8
ab
|
19.0
pq
|
91.5
efg
|
100
a
|
77.3A
|
Acid|
50%| 30 min
|
95.0
cde
|
18.0
q
|
89.5
efghi
|
97.0
bcd
|
74.9
B
|
Acid|
75%| 10 min
|
27.0
op
|
3.5
rs
|
3.5
rs
|
3.5rs
|
9.4
G
|
Acid|
75%| 15 min
|
8.5
r
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
2.1
H
|
Acid|
75%| 20 min
|
5.5
rs
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
1.4
H
|
Acid|
75%| 25 min
|
1.5
s
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.4
HI
|
Acid|
75%| 30 min
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
I
|
Acid|
100%| 10 min
|
0.0
t
|
0.0t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
I
|
Acid|
100%| 15 min
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
I
|
Acid|
100%| 20 min
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
I
|
Acid|
100%| 25 min
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
I
|
Acid|
100%| 30 min
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0
t
|
0.0 t
|
0.0
I
|
Mean
|
42.9
B
|
18.0
D
|
39.1
C
|
49.0
A
|
|
1Data followed by the
same small letters (capital letters for Means) are not significantly different
according to Tukey’s test at 1% level.
Seed
MDG was significantly different among turfgrass genera (Table 2). Cynodon had
the highest MDG and thereafter were Poa| Lolium and Festuca|
respectively (Table 2). These results are similar to those of GP| except for
the superiority of Cynodon to Poa (Tables 1 and 2).
Table
2. Effects of different turfgrass genera| acid treatments and their
interactions on seed MDG.
|
MDG
|
Treatments
|
Turfgrass
genera
|
|
Cynodon
|
Festuca
|
Lolium
|
Poa
|
Mean
|
Control
|
1.8
qr1
|
1.7
r
|
2.3
p
|
3.7
klmn
|
2.4
I
|
Acid|
25%| 10 min
|
6.4
g
|
0.9
stu
|
2.4
op
|
4.1
ijk
|
3.4
H
|
Acid|
25%| 15 min
|
6.6
fg
|
3.4
n
|
2.3
p
|
4.0
ijkl
|
4.1
EF
|
Acid|
25%| 20 min
|
7.0
f
|
2.8
o
|
2.2
pq
|
4.0
ijkl
|
4.0
FG
|
Acid|
25%| 25 min
|
7.8
e
|
0.9
stu
|
2.4
op
|
4.3
hij
|
3.9
G
|
Acid|
25%| 30 min
|
9.2
d
|
0.9
stu
|
2.6
op
|
4.4
hi
|
4.3
E
|
Acid|
50%| 10 min
|
10.4
c
|
1.2
st
|
7.0
f
|
4.6
h
|
5.8
C
|
Acid|
50%| 15 min
|
10.4
c
|
0.9
stu
|
3.6
lmn
|
16.7
b
|
7.9
B
|
Acid|
50%| 20 min
|
49.0
a
|
0.8
stu
|
3.7
klmn
|
16.7
b
|
17.5
A
|
Acid|
50%| 25 min
|
49.4
a
|
0.8
stu
|
3.8
klmn
|
16.7
b
|
17.6
A
|
Acid|
50%| 30 min
|
10.5
c
|
0.7
tuv
|
3.9
jklm
|
4.6
h
|
4.9
D
|
Acid|
75%| 10 min
|
3.4
mn
|
0.1
x
|
0.2
wx
|
0.3
vwx
|
1.0
J
|
Acid|
75%| 15 min
|
1.2
s
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.3
K
|
Acid|
75%| 20 min
|
0.6
uvw
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.1
KL
|
Acid|
75%| 25 min
|
0.2
wx
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
L
|
Acid|
75%| 30 min
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
L
|
Acid|
100%| 10 min
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
L
|
Acid|
100%| 15 min
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
L
|
Acid|
100%| 20 min
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
L
|
Acid|
100%| 25 min
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
L
|
Acid|
100%| 30 min
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
x
|
0.0
L
|
Mean
|
8.3
A
|
0.7
D
|
1.7
C
|
4.0
B
|
|
1Data followed by the
same small letters (capital letters for Means) are not significantly different
according to Tukey’s test at 1% level.
Among
acid treatments| similar to seed GP results| 50% acid used for 10-25 min
resulted in the highest seed MDG| especially in 20 and 25 min treatments (Tables
1 and 2). Usually| with the greater seed GP| the higher seed MDG was obtained.
Acid concentrations higher than 50% is hazardous to turfgrass seeds and can not
be recommended (Tables 1and 2).
Each
turfgrass genus responded significantly to acid treatments in regard to both
seed GP and MDG (Tables 1 and 2). The best treatments were: Cynodon| 50%
acid for 20-25min; Festuca| 25% acid for 15 min; Lolium| 50% acid
for 10 min and Poa| 50% acid for 15-25 min (Tables 1 and 2).
Experiment
2.
Effects
of light and/or dark conditions on seed GPs and MDGs are shown in Table 3. Cynodon
and Festuca had the highest seed GPs and MDGs in 16/8 light/dark
treatment. In Lolium| light and/or dark conditions did not affected seed
GP| but had the highest MDG in dark condition. In Poa| without acid
treatment| the 16/8 light/dark condition was the best| but with acid treatment|
dark condition resulted in highest seed MDG. This may be attributed due to
interaction between light and acid treatments in this genus.
Table
3. Comparison between seed GP or MDG in four turfgrass genera under light
and/or dark conditions.
|
GP
|
MDG
|
Treatments
|
Turfgrass
genera
|
Turfgrass
genera
|
|
Cynodon
|
Festuca
|
Lolium
|
Poa
|
Cynodon
|
Festuca
|
Lolium
|
Poa
|
Control|
16/8 light/dark
|
47 b2
|
44
bc
|
60 b
|
90 b
|
1.9
c
|
1.8
bc
|
2.4
d
|
3.6
c
|
Control|
dark
|
20 c
|
38 c
|
74 b
|
78 c
|
1.0
c
|
1.5
c
|
3.7
c
|
3.1
d
|
Acid
treatments1and 16/8 light/dark
|
100
a
|
85 a
|
98 a
|
100
a
|
50.0
a
|
3.4
a
|
7.5
b
|
16.7
b
|
Acid
treatments and dark
|
50 b
|
55 b
|
92 a
|
100
a
|
12.5
b
|
2.2
b
|
9.2
a
|
25.0
a
|
1Cynodon:
50% acid for 20 min; Festuca: 25% acid for 15 min; Lolium: 50%
acid for 10 min and Poa: 50% acid for 15 min.
2In each column| means
followed by the same letters are not significantly different according to
Tukey’s test at 1% level.
In present study| acid
treatments raised the seed GPs to| or near to| 100% (except in the Festuca)
(Table 3). With regard to MDGs| total germination periods in Cynodon| Poa
and Lolium were only 2| 4 and 10 days| respectively (Table 3). ISTA
(1999) recommended 21 days germination period for Cynodon seeds after
KNO3 treatment. ISTA (1999) also have known Poa pratensis L.
as a slow to germinate turfgrass. According to results obtained in this
experiment| acid treatment can be a very good and simple procedure for
enhancing seed germination of turfgrass genera| especially for Cynodon
and Poa. Seed priming have been used successfully for better emergence
of some turfgrass genera (Young et al.| 1977; Fujikura et al.|
1993; Yamamoto et al.| 1997). Apparently| acid treatment dehulled the
seeds (figure 1). Dehulled seeds can absorb water easily| and rinsing and
placing under running tap water after acid treatment can prepared them for
germination. This treatment is in part similar to “accelerated germination” a
seed hydration treatment suggested by Young et al.| 1977| in
addition to seed dehullation.
Figure 1. Comparison between control (left) and
acid-treated (right) seeds in each turfgrass genus (Cynodon: 50% acid
for 20 min; Festuca: 25% acid for 15 min; Lolium: 50% acid for 10
min and Poa: 50% acid for 15 min).
Acknowledgements:
Authors
wish to convey their appreciation to Mr. H. Azarakhsh and Mr. F. Nikbakht for
technical assistance and Mrs. Z. Seddighi for pretyping the manuscript.
References:
Argel| P.J. and Paton| C.J. (1999). Overcoming
legume hardseededness. In Forage Seed Production| (eds.
D.S. Loch and J.E. Ferguson)| vol. 2| pp. 247-256.
Bai| Y. (2001). Tissue Culture and Genetic
Transformation of Tall Fescue. Ph.D. Thesis| North Carolina State
University| N.C.
Beckman| J.J.| Moser| L.E.| Kubik| K. and
Waller| S.S. (1993). Big bluestem and switchgrass establishments as influenced
by seed priming. Agronomy Journal| 85| 199-202.
Fujikura| Y.| Kraak|
H.S.| Basra| A.S. and Karssen| C.M. (1993). Hydropriming|
a simple and inexpensive priming method. Seed Science and Technology|
21| 639-645.
International Seed Testing Association (1999).
International Rules for Seed Testing. Seed Science and Technology| 27|
Supplement| 333pp.
Simpson| G.M. (1990). Seed Dormancy in
Grasses. Cambridge University Press| London.
Tigabu| M. and Oden| P.C. (2001). Effect of
scarification| gibberellic acid and temperature on seed germination of two
multipurpose Albizia species from Ethiopia. Seed Science and
Technology| 29| 11-20.
Trask| M.M. and Pyke| D.A. (1998). Variability
in seed dormancy of three Pacific Northwestern grasses. Seed Science and
Technology| 26| 179-191.
Turgeon| A.J. (2002). Turfgrass Management| 6th
ed.| Prentice Hall Pub.| New Jersey. 400p.
Yamamoto| I.| Turgeon| A.J. and Duich| J.M.
(1997). Field emergence of solid matrix seed primed turfgrasses. Crop
Science| 37| 220-225.
Young| J.A.| Kay| B.L. and Evans| R.A. (1977).
Accelerating the germination of common Bermudagrasses for hydroseeding. Agronomy
Journal| 69| 115-119.
Zar| J. (1996). Biostatistical Analysis. 3rd
edition| pp. 277-284| Prentice Hall| Inc.| Upper Saddle River| N.J.